Tue, 21 Jul 2026 Kyiv 16:00Berlin 15:00London 14:00 UKR / DE / EN

Armin Nassehi: Germans’ Grumbling Has a Political Function

Sociologist Armin Nassehi challenges Friedrich Merz's claim that Germans are a chronically grumbling nation. In an interview with Tagesspiegel, he explains why criticism of the government can also be an expression of deep-seated elite criticism.

Armin Nassehi: Germans’ Grumbling Has a Political Function
Photo: tagesspiegel.de

Sociologist Armin Nassehi challenges Friedrich Merz's claim that Germans are a chronically grumbling nation. In an interview with Tagesspiegel, he explains why criticism of the government can also be an expression of deep-seated elite criticism.

Friedrich Merz recently complained again about the “eternal grumbling” of Germans in a summer interview. Sociologist Armin Nassehi sees it differently: The discontent is not simply a character trait but has a political function. In an interview with Tagesspiegel, he explains his counter-thesis.

Asked whether Merz’s diagnosis of a chronically grumbling country is accurate, Nassehi gives a nuanced response. One must distinguish between concrete criticism of the federal government’s policies and a generalized, undifferentiated expression of displeasure. The latter, the “badmouthing,” does exist. But the grumbling Merz complains about is part of an elite criticism that is currently stronger than ever.

Nassehi thus questions the chancellor’s implicit assumption: It is not the people who are the problem, but the relationship between the governed and the governing. The persistent criticism is an expression of distrust toward political decision-makers – and thus a serious signal, not mere whining.

Source: www.tagesspiegel.de