The German government wants to house rejected asylum seekers who cannot be sent back to their home countries in “return hubs” outside the EU. Now the European and international law unit of the Bundestag’s scientific services warns that an agreement between governments alone may not be enough. “A law could be required for the project,” the opinion says, according to Handelsblatt.
The paper, titled “On the need for a national legal basis for return hubs”, was completed on 16 October 2026. It was commissioned by an individual MP and expressly does not reflect the Bundestag’s position, so it is not a court ruling. Politically it still matters, because it goes to the heart of Interior Minister Alexander Dobrindt’s timetable.
Why a deal alone may not be enough
The basis is the new EU return regulation, which the Council adopted on 1 October 2026, according to the opinion. Article 14 requires an “agreement or arrangement” with the third country, excludes unaccompanied minors and allows families with children. The lawyers consider a binding treaty the obvious route; informal understandings are “rather unlikely” to suffice. Under Article 59(2) of the Basic Law such a treaty would probably need the Bundestag’s consent.
There is also a fundamental-rights argument: someone transferred to a country with which they have no connection sees their legal status and access to courts change, which points to parliamentary involvement. Nor may the government label a binding treaty a mere declaration of intent to bypass the Bundestag.
Timetable, numbers, resistance
After meeting counterparts from Denmark, the Netherlands, Austria and Greece on 4 September, Dobrindt said an agreement with a partner state should come “this year”. Rwanda confirmed talks at the end of August. According to Handelsblatt, Germany, Austria and three other EU states plan a centre there, with transfers possible from 2027; Uganda and Uzbekistan are also mentioned. Constance law professor Daniel Thym expects an initial pilot of about 20 people from Germany, the paper reports, against roughly 240,000 people legally obliged to leave. The practical effect would be small at first.
The European legal picture is open too. After the political deal between Council and Parliament on 2 June, an agreement with a third country is a precondition for any hub. The EU Court of Justice has a case on Italy’s Albania model pending; the Advocate General’s April opinion is not binding. Caritas speaks of a “legal grey zone”, the International Rescue Committee warns of prison-like conditions, and French President Macron said in June the concept was neither effective nor in line with French principles. The UK’s Rwanda scheme cost about €830 million and was never implemented. Handelsblatt reports resistance forming within the coalition as well.
Our assessment: if the Bundestag has to approve a treaty, an executive negotiation becomes an open parliamentary fight. We think it unlikely that Dobrindt meets his 2026 goal; a ratified agreement before mid-2027 would be ambitious. That is not certain, and depends on whether the government takes the treaty route.
Ukrainians with temporary protection under Section 24 of the Residence Act are, on current information, not the target group: the hubs are meant for rejected asylum seekers who cannot be returned to their countries of origin.
Sources: Bundestag scientific services, Handelsblatt, LTO, ZDFheute



