On Wednesday 18 November, Germany’s Federal Constitutional Court is due to publish its ruling on a complaint by the Sahra Wagenknecht Alliance (BSW) over the 23 February 2025 federal election (case 2 BvC 4/26). The question is explosive: were votes miscounted, and would the party be in parliament without those errors?
The BSW won 4.981 per cent of the party-list vote, 9,529 votes short of the five per cent threshold nationwide. It alleges counting mistakes and statistical anomalies that were not fully corrected when the result was finalised. By its own calculation it would hold 35 seats, and the black-red coalition would no longer have a majority on its own, as LTO and ZDF report. On 18 December 2025 the Bundestag rejected a recount by 427 votes to 129, with one abstention, following the election-review committee, which Christian Democrats, Social Democrats, Greens and the Left backed. The committee found no violation of electoral law that affected seat allocation.
Why the bar is so high
A narrow margin is not enough. Anyone demanding a recount must prove concrete errors and show they could have changed the seat distribution. That is where the BSW has so far fallen short: in May 2025 the court dismissed two of its suits, and earlier emergency applications failed because the party first had to go through the election-review procedure. According to press reports, the rapporteur is Ann-Katrin Kaufhold, vice-president of the court and chair of its Second Senate. The ruling appears to come without an oral hearing. Sahra Wagenknecht told the RND this was “remarkable” and said it would only make sense if the court ordered a recount.
Whether that reading holds is unclear: deciding election complaints on paper is not unusual when the court considers a case ready for judgment, and it can go either way.
Three possible outcomes
First, the court dismisses the complaint. In our assessment this is the most likely result, given the high burden of proof and the Bundestag’s broad majority – though nothing is certain. Seat distribution would stay as it is.
Second, Karlsruhe demands a targeted check of individual constituencies or invalid ballots. The BSW has argued that re-examining invalid votes alone could lift it over five per cent. According to ZDF, a successful complaint would at least trigger a recount at the polling stations concerned. Even then, a final result would take months.
Third, the court orders a full national recount. That would be an unprecedented intervention mid-term and is widely seen as unlikely.
Politically, even the second scenario would matter: if the BSW crossed five per cent, the parliamentary majority would be reshuffled, with consequences for Ukraine policy, since the party opposes arms deliveries to Kyiv. That is the newsroom’s assessment; what counts is what Karlsruhe actually rules. The decision is expected on the court’s website from about 9:30 CET. We will update this piece when it is out.
Sources: Federal Constitutional Court (schedule notice), LTO, dpa via inFranken, ZDFheute



