The votes for the BSW in the 2025 Bundestag election do not have to be recounted. The Second Senate of the Federal Constitutional Court dismissed the party’s election review complaint as inadmissible, as the court announced in Karlsruhe. The order is dated 20 October and has now been published; according to ZDFheute and WELT, the decision was unanimous.
In its reasoning, the court stated: “The complainants do not meet the requirements to be placed on the reasoning of an election review complaint. They do not present a sufficiently specific set of facts from which it would follow what a mandate-relevant election error is supposed to consist of.” The statement continues: “The mere suggestion of the possibility of election errors or the expression of an unsubstantiated presumption do not satisfy the requirements for asserting an election error. This also applies to pointing out a large number of mere possibilities of election errors.”
Among the four complainants was party founder Sahra Wagenknecht. She reacted sharply: “Now it is official: Germany has the election review of a banana republic – with the blessing of the highest court,” she declared, according to WELT. In future, a review of narrow election results would have no chance, “which would mean that in future even real election fraud would be possible without the affected party being able to defend itself against it”. The “misjudgement” does not “guard the constitution, but harms democracy”. According to WELT, Wagenknecht intends to examine further legal steps.
The party leadership also criticised the court. BSW chair Fabio De Masi spoke of a “black day for democracy” and declared that his trust in the institutions of the rule of law had been “severely shaken”. His co-chair Amira Mohamed Ali called the refusal to recount a scandal: “This leaves it unresolved whether the Bundestag is correctly composed and whether the roughly 2.5 million BSW voters are wrongly being denied their parliamentary representation.”
9,529 votes were missing – and a name that was confused
The Bündnis Sahra Wagenknecht – which is now called Bündnis Soziale Gerechtigkeit und Wirtschaftliche Vernunft – narrowly failed the five-percent threshold in February 2025 with 4.981 percent of the second votes. With a total of 2,472,947 votes, 9,529 votes were missing nationwide, as the Süddeutsche Zeitung and fr.de report. The party assumes that it should actually have 35 MPs in parliament. Then all mandates would be distributed differently, and the current black-red coalition would not have a majority on its own.
After the election, the BSW had initiated its own reviews and found “anomalies”. For example, BSW votes were said to have been attributed mainly to the party Bündnis Deutschland because of the similarity of names. In addition, valid BSW votes were said to have been overlooked because the party was placed unfavourably on the ballot paper. In its own projection, the BSW arrived at a “potential of wrongly counted BSW votes” of around 33,000.
Before the announcement, Wagenknecht had told the Deutsche Presse-Agentur: “Everything suggests that Merz is wrongly chancellor and that the current Bundestag is not composed in accordance with the constitution.” At the same time, she conceded: “More evidence and indications of counting errors to the detriment of the BSW cannot be put on the table without access to the ballot papers.”
A further setback for a party on a downward trend
On 18 December 2025, the Bundestag rejected an application by the BSW and other individuals for a recount. The election review complaint in Karlsruhe was directed against this. The procedure is anchored in the Basic Law: first the parliament decides, only then can the judges be called upon. They examine whether the electoral law was applied correctly and whether this is compatible with the Basic Law – and whether an error would be mandate-relevant. It was not the first attempt: already in March 2025 the Second Senate rejected several applications by the BSW, and in May 2025 it dismissed two organ complaints, which concerned, among other things, the order of the parties on the ballot paper.
The defeat in Karlsruhe is a further severe setback for the BSW, founded in 2024. Since the party is no longer represented in the Bundestag, it has less attention, its poll ratings have fallen, and two of three state elections this autumn were lost. Only in Saxony-Anhalt did it manage to clear the five-percent threshold; the parliamentary cooperation there with the AfD is causing disputes within the BSW.
Editorial assessment: With the order, the legal route in the matter is exhausted. For the party, this means that it can in future carry its thesis of the stolen mandate only politically – without any prospect of a judicial correction. The long duration of the proceedings, which ZDF legal expert Daniel Heymann views critically, is unlikely to have strengthened trust in the election review.
Earlier coverage: BSW election challenge: what Karlsruhe could rule on Wednesday



