The Bundesrat has for now blocked the Startchancengesetz with mandatory language and development tests for four-year-olds in Kitas and called in the mediation committee. The chamber of the Länder decided this on Friday, 20 November, in Berlin with a clear majority, as n-tv.de and Bayerischer Rundfunk report. The federal government and the Länder are now to find a compromise in the joint body.
The Länder explicitly support the substance of the federal government’s plan. The point of dispute is money: the federal government wants to gradually reduce its financial support for this task until 2035, and the Länder see this as shifting the costs onto themselves and the municipalities. The Bundestag had only passed the law on 12 November.
What the law provides for – and what it costs
Under the law, four-year-olds are in future to be tested throughout Germany according to uniform standards for language and development, including first mathematical skills. Where needed, the children are to receive special support. The assessment of language and development level is to become mandatory in Kitas nationwide from 2029, which means greater staffing requirements. According to ludwigsburg24.com, the language assessments are to apply fully to all children from 2029, and tests in other development areas from 2032. Kitas with particularly many children in challenging circumstances are to receive more staff.
According to ludwigsburg24.com, the federal government intends to support the Länder with a total of around 9.25 billion euros from 2027 to 2034, with its contribution declining each year. Specifically, according to n-tv.de, around 1.5 billion euros are planned for each of 2027 and 2028, then 1.24 billion euros in 2029 and 993 million euros annually thereafter. In 2034, federal funding is to end completely.
“Education is not available free of charge”
The responsible Bundesrat committees point to the principle of Veranlassungskonnexität agreed in the coalition agreement: whoever initiates additional tasks should also ensure their financing. The federal government had previously rejected the Länder’s financial demands and argued that the costs were more likely to be overestimated; however, the Länder counter that no reliable cost calculation for this has yet been presented.
Several state ministers spoke in the debate. “If the federal government provides for new tasks, it must also contribute to their financing,” said Berlin’s education senator Katharina Günther-Wünsch of the CDU, according to n-tv.de. “Education is not available free of charge,” said North Rhine-Westphalia’s family minister Verena Schäffer of the Greens. “The federal government cannot prescribe new, additional standards for us and at the same time withdraw from financing.” Saarland’s education minister Christine Streichert-Clivot of the SPD demanded: “The law must be improved.”
Federal education minister Karin Prien campaigned for a compromise and showed willingness to make concessions. “But it must also be clear: the implementation of childcare is an original task of the Länder and municipalities, including financing,” she stressed. She said the federal government had already accommodated the Länder on key points in the process so far, for example planned standards on general staffing levels had been removed. Mecklenburg-Vorpommern’s minister-president Manuela Schwesig of the SPD said it was good that the federal government continued to provide funds for childcare; but the price must not be that “the funds for early childhood education are lost” as a result.
One Land leads the way – and many other projects go through
Baden-Württemberg already relies on its own support programme with “SprachFit”. Since the 2026/2027 school year, there have been junior classes there as an additional support year before year 1 for school-age children with intensive support needs. In the 2026/2027 and 2027/2028 school years, parents decide on participation; from 2028/2029, the school management decides on mandatory attendance, as ludwigsburg24.com reports.
While the Kita law now hangs in the mediation committee, the chamber of the Länder gave the green light to other projects. The so-called Frühstartrente can enter into force retroactively from the start of 2026: the state pays ten euros a month into an individual retirement savings account for six- to 18-year-olds, and parents or grandparents can top it up with up to 6,840 euros a year. The programme begins with the 2020 birth cohort, and from 2027 the cohort of those then aged six is added each year. If parents do not open their own account, the funding flows into a newly created special fund.
The reform of emergency care was also approved. At many hospital sites, central contact points are initially to make an assessment and, depending on urgency, refer patients to the emergency department or a nearby emergency service practice; such an initial assessment is also to be possible via the service number 116 117. According to Bayerischer Rundfunk, the decisive factor was a protocol declaration submitted at short notice by the federal government that takes up central criticisms of the Länder and promises corrections. The Bundesrat also approved the “d-you” app as a digital wallet, which is to make it possible to show ID via smartphone from the beginning of next year, as well as the driving licence reform, which is intended to make obtaining a licence cheaper – according to the federal government, a driving licence currently costs an average of 3,400 euros, at best up to 1,000 euros less.
For families with four-year-olds, everything therefore remains as before for the time being: there are not yet any mandatory, nationwide uniform tests. How quickly the mediation committee reaches an agreement is open – the law can only enter into force once the Bundestag and Bundesrat support the compromise.



