The COP31 world climate conference in Antalya ended on Sunday without a final declaration. Conference president Murat Kurum, the Turkish environment minister, withdrew the ‘Antalya Pact’ submitted by the Turkish-Australian conference leadership in the closing plenary after the explicit objection of the European Union and other states, as the Berliner Zeitung reports, citing the news agency AFP. According to Der Spiegel, the negotiations had previously been extended by almost 44 hours – the conference thus surpassed the previous record of COP25 in Madrid in 2019 and was the longest world climate conference of all time.
In the closing session, Kurum conceded: “I understand that there is no agreement on this text. For this reason, these decisions have not been adopted,” as news.un.org reports. Shortly beforehand, he had still spoken of a “historic opportunity”, as WirtschaftsWoche writes.
Why the EU said no
The ten-page draft did not explicitly name coal, oil and gas. Instead, it referred only in general terms to the decision taken in Dubai in 2023 to phase out fossil fuels, as Der Spiegel and the Berliner Zeitung report in agreement. Ireland’s climate minister Darragh O’Brien, whose country currently holds the EU Council presidency, said on behalf of the EU: “The EU firmly rejects this text.” It would not accept a final declaration that does not even mention fossil fuels. According to the Berliner Zeitung, O’Brien told AFP that the proposal fell “nowhere near” the necessary efforts in any area.
Panama and the Marshall Islands also refused their approval. “Panama cannot support this decision,” a representative of the country declared in the plenary. The chief diplomat of the Marshall Islands, whose homeland is threatened by rising sea levels, called the text, according to WirtschaftsWoche, the “worst possible response” to the climate crisis. Der Spiegel also reports criticism from the United Kingdom and Norway.
German environment minister Carsten Schneider (SPD) had already rejected the draft on the morning of the same day: “The text as finally presented to us in the third version is not acceptable to Germany,” he said before journalists in Antalya. A regression behind climate protection agreements already achieved was “not acceptable at all”. A few hours before the end of the conference, Schneider set off on his journey home.
Guterres: “We cannot extinguish the fire while pouring fuel on it”
UN Secretary-General António Guterres reacted “deeply disappointed”. “I share the very deep frustration of all those who had expected governments to rise to the demands of the climate crisis,” he said, according to tagesschau.de. The main cause of climate change was the continued dependence on coal, oil and gas. “There may be no consensus in the negotiating room. In science there is no ambiguity,” Guterres said, according to news.un.org. The world was heading towards exceeding the internationally agreed limit of 1.5 degrees.
According to the UN chief, influential actors from the fossil fuel industry distort scientific findings, delay policy measures and accumulate enormous profits – methods already known from the tobacco industry. Addressing civil society, he said: “Keep spreading the facts. Keep demanding action. Keep turning up the heat.”
Criticism of Merz and the German government
The Green parliamentary group leader Katharina Dröge called the failure a “fatal result for climate protection”. It was right that the EU had refused to sign “such a bad document”, she said, according to tagesschau.de. But it was also “a major mistake by the German government and also by the EU that they attached so little importance to the world climate conference”. Federal Chancellor Friedrich Merz (CDU) had “completely skipped” the conference. Green co-leader Franziska Brantner told the ARD capital studio that the German government shared responsibility: anyone who said “please all heat with gas instead of renewables” also had an impact on international negotiations.
The Left party’s climate expert Violetta Bock criticised that the EU itself had arrived empty-handed and had been among the blockers of internationally just financing. “Anyone who really wants the phase-out must ensure that fossil lobbyists have no access to climate conferences and do their homework at home instead of watering down climate targets themselves,” she said.
The president of the German Environment Agency, Dirk Messner, on the other hand, defended the EU states’ no: “A text that does not adequately name the phase-out of coal, oil and gas would have set us back.” The world was split into a camp that drives climate protection forward and a camp of defenders of oil, coal and gas. A large share of states were working on the climate-neutral transformation and were refusing “disruptive manoeuvres from countries such as Saudi Arabia and Russia”.
Not a failure across the board
Environmentalists did not necessarily want to see the outcome as a defeat. Jan Kowalzig of Oxfam, according to tagesschau.de, spoke of a “sign that the majority of countries did not allow themselves to be brought to their knees by the blockers of a fossil phase-out”. At the same time, the result was also due to the EU’s lack of flexibility on financial support for poorer countries – that had prevented alliances. Susann Scherbarth of BUND said Schneider was bringing “heavy baggage home after this shamefully disappointing climate conference”.
WirtschaftsWoche points out that without a final declaration, not nothing was decided: around 30 states have submitted or announced their own plans to phase out coal, oil and gas, and in July dozens of states want to meet in the Pacific island state of Tuvalu. Germany, the EU and twelve other states want to take stronger action against the greenhouse gas SF6, and dozens of states support a Turkish initiative to increase the share of electricity in global final energy consumption from 23 to 35 per cent. All earlier decisions of the climate conferences remain valid.
The climate summit was originally supposed to end on Friday evening. According to news.un.org, the next conference, COP32, will take place in Addis Ababa in Ethiopia – many of the questions left open in Antalya are likely to be on the table again there.



